In the text of this hadith narration, "Walid said, Muhammad b. I heard from Ali ..
"Muhammad b. Ali " instead of " Haddeseni muhaddisun " statement passes. Some scholars who pointed out that the word "Muhammad" passed in the printed copy, pointed out that this was not true. (bk.el-urfu'l-verdi fi ahbari'l-mahdi, p.6)
This may be intended to mean "a madhhad / madhhist scholarship" , as well as a meaning of "someone whom I talked to told me about"
In this case , the word "Muhaddis" has been specifically chosen because it has evoked "hadith scholarship" .Regardless of the meaning of this " Muhaddis " word of the year, this note is weak because it has both a maktu and an unknown ravi.
As a matter of fact, Dr. Abu Suhayb Khalid al-Hayik also stated that the narration had an unknown ravioli in it and that the hadith was "a manger " . (see Daru'l-hadisi-diyaiye)Al-Suyuti in having his book, Sufyan died dürülü where "mercy " and not "Rahbet" as is ticking. (see 2/86)
EmoticonEmoticon